Rogueing at Meadowview Research Farms

Published April 13, 2017

In the quest to create a population of blight resistant American chestnut trees through backcross breeding, large numbers of trees have been planted and screened for resistance to chestnut blight. We aim to select the 1% most blight-resistant trees that will be a source of seed for restoration. Since 2002, over 60,000 American chestnut backcross trees have been planted in seed orchards at TACF’s Meadowview Research Farms. As these trees are planted, we have been inoculating them at age two with the fungus that causes chestnut blight. Susceptible trees that develop large and sunken blight cankers are removed. As of January 2017, there were 8246 trees remaining in Meadowview seed orchards. Our final goal is to cull all but 500 to 600 of the most resistant trees.

Steve Hoy, orchard manager with the PA/NJ Chapter, rogueing at Meadowview Research Farms.

This winter, we visually assessed all remaining trees. Trees that demonstrated symptoms of susceptibility, including those with a dead main stem and large sunken cankers, were removed. Dan Mckinnon, our seed orchard supervisor and Steve Hoy from the Pennsylvania chapter of TACF, carefully removed many trees that were planted at close spacing, some as close as one foot apart! Together they removed a total of 2,705 trees leaving 5,500 trees.

To make final selections in the Meadowview seed orchards, we are screening progeny of a subset of the remaining trees for resistance to chestnut blight. It is not feasible to screen progeny from all remaining trees. To speed up selection, we are estimating the relationships between DNA sequence variation and the average canker sizes of the progeny from mother trees that vary in their genetic levels of resistance to chestnut blight.

Through understanding the relationships between DNA sequence and blight resistance, we aim to predict the underlying genetic resistance of remaining selections from DNA sequence alone. This method, called genomic selection will enable us to pick the winners more accurately (i.e., the most genetically resistant trees) and significantly speed up the process, allowing us to cull the rest in as little as three years!


Watch this video of Dan cutting down a Chinese chestnut tree that had been planted in the Wagner seed orchard at Meadowview Research farms.

Sara Fitzsimmons in 2005 with Jim Gage, Dr Phil Arnold, Dr Robert Gregg

2005
Sara Fern Fitzsimmons with Jim Gage, Dr Phil Arnold, & Dr Robert Gregg

2006, Sara Fitzsimmons pollinates at Stockers

2006
Sara pollinating at Stockers, PA

Sara rating cankers at Thorpewood

Sara rating cankers at Thorpewood, MD

Sara at the 25th Annual TACF meeting

2008
Sara at the 25th Annual TACF Meeting

Sara and the Graves tree

2009
Sara in the PSU Graves Orchard

Sara Fern Fitzsimmons in the Glenn Swank stump, 2009

2009
Sara in the Glenn Swank stump, PA

Sara at the International Chestnut Symposium, 2012

2012
Sara at the International Chestnut Symposium

Sara in Vermont

2014
Sara with Harmony Dalgleish and the Berlin American chestnut in Vermont

Kendra and Sara in the field

Sara and Kendra Collins working in the field

Sara presenting at the 2022 TACF Spring Meeting

2022
Sara presenting at TACF’s Spring Meeting

Sara (in the rocker) with TACF staff at the Fall Meeting

2023
Sara (in the rocker) with TACF staff at the Fall Meeting

Sara Fern Fitzsimmons

2024
Sara in the Penn State greenhouses